نموذج المراجعة

Paper No.:

Manuscript Title:

Excellent

V. good

Good

Accepted

Weak

Evaluation Elements

No.

Does  the title  clearly, concisely  and accurately reflect  the content of the  research?

1

Are the research objectives clearly stated, and does the study consistently address them?

2

Does the abstract effectively summarize the research and its main findings?

3

Is the research methodology appropriate and well-suited for the study's purpose?

4

Are the conclusions presented clearly and effectively?

5

Are the data analyses accurate and reliable?

6

Does the discussion logically connect with and support the study's conclusions?

7

Are any figures and tables relevant and well-integrated into the research?

8

Are the references current and appropriately chosen for the topic?

9

Are all sources cited accurately and honestly?

11

Is the language of the research grammatically correct and clear?

12

Does the research offer a novel contribution to its field of study?

13

Rejected

Acceptable for publication after major revisions

Acceptable for publications after minor revisions

Acceptable for publication without corrections

□

□

□

□

Name:

Country:

Mobile:

E-mail:

University:

College:

Department: